Addressing institutional challenges in the new millennium report by the consultative board to the directorgeneral supachai panitchpakdi geneva. The report on the future of the wto had a serious challenge to face. While affirming that the wto represents the most dramatic advance in multilateralism since the 1940s, the report worries that the organization is not by any means fully. The future scope of wto issues as seen in the sutherland report. While affirming that the wto represents \u22the most dramatic advance in multilateralism\u22 since the 1940s, the report worries that the organization \u22is not by any. Apr 08, 2010 published on the occasion of the 10th anniversary of the world trade organization, the socalled sutherland report was to address institutional challenges in the new millennium. Wagner, markus max planck institute for comparative public law and international law, max planck society. Addressing institutional challenges in the new millenium geneva. The secretarygeneral has the honour to transmit to the general assembly the report submitted to him by his special representative on migration, mr. M ovsesian ten years after the organizations founding, an air of disappointment sur rounds the wto. Among them are globalization, nondiscrimi nation, sovereignty, coherence, and dispute. If the wto were to expand into substantive regulatory areas like environmental protection, the potential for interference with sensitive domestic.
Breaking the deadlock on market access for least developed countries 96 kimberly ann elliott 5. This essay evaluates the treatment of dispute settlement in the recently issued sutherland report on the future of the wto. C ass the world trade organization is at the cusp of a significant stage in its institutional development. The sutherland report on wto reform a critical appraisal. On the one hand, it had to avoid charybdis the temptation of a cozy status quo, natural in such a complex institution shaped by fifty years of creative ambiguity and customary practices that evolved into quasir.
The doha development round, launched in 2001 in an. Jan 01, 2005 the sutherland report and the theory of wto law 219 the sutherland report and the theory of wto law c hi c armody the recent report of the consultative board to the wto directorgeneral, referred to as the sutherland report, deals with a number of key issues in the present and future of the wto. A missed opportunity for genuine debate on trade, globalization and reforming the wto. Jan 01, 2005 the sutherland report and the wtos institutional law 191 the sutherland report and the wtos institutional law d o p arallels with o ther i nternational o rganizations h elp. A similar approach has been taken by wto directorgeneral supachai panitchpakdi who called peter sutherland, jagdish bhagwati, kwesi. Key issues for policy coherence for development oecd. Pdf the sutherland report on wto reform a critical appraisal. Development, international organizations and fairness as. Pdf the sutherland report on wto reform a critical. Using this report the 2016 annual report begins with a message from the wto directorgeneral and an overview of the past year. In 1989, he was the heffernan visiting fellow at the kennedy school of government at harvard university. So while the wto is still young, the multilateral trading system that was originally set up.
Impacts on agriculture, financial sector, and stateowned enterprises pdf. Supachai and how it relates to some of the other things going on in the wto. The sutherland report takes a relatively close look at the operation of the. Although the sutherland report offers a truly thoughtful and interesting analysis, it is largely a defense of the status quo by wto insiders. The sutherland report and dispute settlement by mark. The sutherland report and the theory of wto law 219 the sutherland report and the theory of wto law c hi c armody the recent report of the consultative board to the wto directorgeneral, referred to as the sutherland report, deals with a number of key issues in the present and future of the wto. The development of the wto remarks on the sutherland report.
Peter sutherland, jagdish bhagwati, kwasi botchwey, niall fitzgerald, koichi hamada, john h. A similar approach has been taken by wto directorgeneral supachai panitchpakdi who called peter sutherland, jagdish bhagwati, kwesi botchwey, niall fitzgerald, koichi hamada, john h. The wtos dispute settlement body and its impact on. The development of the wto remarks on the sutherland report 175 requires closer coordination between developing members, something that the report hints at in the following section paras. Challenges facing the wto and policies to address global. The future of the wto addressing institutional challenges in the new millennium report by the consultative board to the former directorgeneral supachai panitchpakdi. World trade organization economics bibliographies cite. I will begin with a little bit about the purpose of that board according to dr.
The world trade organization deals with the global rules of trade between nations. The report is neither experts rocking the politically stuck boat,1 nor outsiders blowing new life into the wto. The sutherland report and dispute settlement 201 the sutherland report and dispute settlement m ark l. Redesigning the world trade organization for the twentyfirst. The views expressed in this report are the opinions of the authors and should not be attributed to the wto or. The great promise of a global trade regime, dedicated to the principle of comparative advantage, seems to have stalled. This thesis discusses the most significant limiting factors reported and practiced by developing countries in the dsb.
While the report is moderate in language and scope, several important elements tend in the direction of strengthening the wto as an institution. Peter sutherland became directorgeneral of the world trade organization on 1 january 1995. A missed opportunity for genuine debate on trade, globalization, and reforming the wto article pdf available in journal of international economic law 82 june 2005. A missed opportunity for genuine debate on trade, globalization and reforming the wto journal of international economic law, vol. This report provides background history of the wto, its organization, and current. He had previously served as directorgeneral of gatt since 1 july 1993.
Addressing institutional challenges in the new millennium, was released on january 17, 2005 in connection with the wto s tenth anniversary. Introduction in june 2003 the directorgeneral of the wto, supachai panitchpakdi, asked a group of wise men, the socalled consultative board, under the chairmanship of former director. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise cambridge core to connect with your account. Press release sutherland outlines challenges and benefits for china in gatt membership negotiations.
The wto officially commenced on 1 january 1995 under the marrakesh agreement, signed by 123 nations on 15 april 1994, replacing the general agreement on tariffs and trade gatt, which commenced in 1948. Addressing institutional challenges in the new millennium, was released on january 17, 2005 in connection with the wtos tenth anniversary. Rebuilding the wto for a sustainable global development. This commentary analyzes the report s underlying notion of the organizations selfunderstanding and critically scrutinizes this approach. This particular conference was held at columbia university in the spring of 2006. The sutherland report more properly, the report by the consultative board on the future of the wtoreflects this sense of unease about the organization\u27s apparent drift. The report not only focuses on institutional improvements, but also responded to some criticisms of the wto that, in the cbs view, have been greatly.
Decisionmaking and transparency in the medieval wto. The sutherland report 1 correctly mentions that the wto dispute settlement process has been highly successful and suggests that, while there are some grounds for criticism and reform of the dispute settlement system, there is much satisfaction with the system and the most important principle is to do no harm to it. Create your citations, reference lists and bibliographies automatically using the apa, mla, chicago, or harvard referencing styles. The uruguay round was the last of a series of periodic trade negotiations held under the auspices of the wtos predecessor. So while the wto is still young, the multilateral trading system that was originally set up under. Among them are globalization, nondiscrimination, sovereignty, coherence, and dispute settlement. The accession of least developed countries to the world trade organization 88 nicolas imboden 4.
These are the sources and citations used to research world trade organization. The sutherland reportmore properly, the report by the consultative board on the future of the wtoreflects this sense of unease about the organizations apparent drift. Challenges facing the wto and policies to address global governance peter sutherland and john sewell chairman, goldman sachs international. This bibliography was generated on cite this for me on sunday, march 8, 2015. Under the dsb, there are many cases that present the limiting of developing countries on some significant ways. The sutherland report and the theory of wto law in. Gatt1634 press release peter sutherland dismisses fears that the world trade organization will infringe national sovereignty as unfounded. Set in the context of the vaticans statement on ethical guidelines for international trade issued in september 2003, the paper advances the concept of the wto as a family of nations. Confronting the challenges a collection of short essays iv 3. Mar 23, 2006 the sutherland report is a report of the consultative board that was composed two and a half years ago by the then wto directorgeneral supachai panitchpakdi. Two highlevel commissionsthe sutherland report in 2004, and the warwick commission report in 2007addressed the future of the world trade organization and made proposals for incremental reform.
One of the youngest of the international organizations, the wto is the successor to the general agreement on tariffs and trade gatt established in the wake of the second world war. The sutherland reportmore properly, the report by the consultative board on the future of the wtoreflects this sense of unease about the organization\u27s apparent drift. Sutherland report and its discussion of dispute settlement. Background and issues summary the world trade organization wto was established on january 1, 1995, under an agreement reached during the uruguay round of multilateral trade negotiations. President, overseas development council origins of the wtos new challenges the multilateral trading system, with the world trade organization wto at its centre, is the most important tool of global eco. Redesigning the world trade organization for the twentyfirst century debra p. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here.
Introduction this comment will focus primarily on the sutherland report s analysis of and recommendations for the wto dispute settlement system. The world trade organization wto is an intergovernmental organization that is concerned with the regulation of international trade between nations. Symposium on the sutherland report the future of the wto. Studies in international governance series copublished by the international development research centre and the centre for international governance innovation.
The world trade organization came into being in 1995. A missed opportunity for genuine debate on trade, globalization and reforming the wto june 1, 2005. The sutherland report more properly, the report by the consultative board on the future of the wtoreflects this sense of unease about the organizations apparent drift. The sutherland report and the wtos institutional law 191 the sutherland report and the wtos institutional law d o p arallels with o ther i nternational o rganizations h elp. Established out of the gatt with that institutions illfunctioning dispute settlement procedures, but durable trade negotiating forum, the wto emerged, in 1995, with a broad. Presentation or lecture press release religious text report software website 2. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. The sutherland report and dispute settlement by mark l. The sutherland report and the theory of wto law by chi carmody1 the recent report of the consultative board to the wto directorgeneral, referred to as the sutherland report, deals with a number of key issues in the present and future of wto. The sutherland report and wto dispute settlement niall meagher 1. In early 2005 a consultative board to the world trade organization wto. Published on the occasion of the 10th anniversary of the world trade organization, the socalled sutherland report was to address institutional challenges in the new millennium. The sutherland report on wto reform cambridge core. Does the sutherland report have the right prescription.
760 152 1419 1568 988 392 395 508 4 910 981 967 614 701 1529 1448 1476 853 889 1457 1185 835 1244 1121 1365 151 1074 895 517 717 1463 748 285 817 1414 831 703 1179 230 1252 30 1230 599 336 1288